Book Meme: Day 04

Day 04 – Your favourite book or series ever

I don’t have just favourite book ever. I can’t. It’s like having a favourite food – how can I judge one taste to be better than another when they’re so different? It’s like comparing oranges to chocolate cake. You can’t.

When I was a kid my favourite series was Nancy Drew. I loved Nancy Drew. So what if she’s an overly perfect 1950s good two-shoes role-model? Even then I recognized that the books were flawed, but I also loved that a female protagonist ran around having adventures and solving crimes with her two best girlfriends, that she was independent and competent and clever and polite. She saved the day. I loved that.

Later on my favourite book series was the Heralds of Valdemar by Mercedes Lackey. In the first book, Arrows of the Queen, a shy 13 year old girl is Chosen by a big white horse to leave her life of drudgery and become the Queen’s right-hand woman, have some adventures, fall in love and generally Fix Everything. Be still my pre-teen heart! It was glorious.

My favourite books now aren’t as easy to identify. I love The Last Unicorn by Peter S. Beagle because it’s a word-for-word replay of one of my favourite movies. (Shush, you. I know the book came first.)  It’s whimsical comfort food.

I’m also a huge fan of Salamander by Thomas Wharton, even though I’ve only read it once and that was over 5 years ago. That book, however, was a faithful friend in a foreign country when I was on a Trip from Hell. It got me through a rough spot and I’ll always be thankful for that. Plus it’s a great novel.

And then there’s the YA book Juniper, by Monica Furlong. It’s about a Cornish princess whose claim to the throne is usurped by the birth of a brother. Instead she is sent off to learn to be a wise woman and hates every second of it. I carried this book around with me for years – it’s small, light, and I could start anywhere and be engrossed. I don’t know if it’s because I identified with the sibling rivalry, or of not fitting in, or because the spoiled, bratty princess actually changed and grew – I loved this book.

Then I bought the sequel (prequel?) Wise Child, and didn’t like it nearly so much. Although I don’t think that’s the book’s fault, but rather mine for having unmeetable expectations. It was like reading Lirael after devouring Garth Nix’s fantabulous Sabriel… it’s impossible to live up to!


Comments are closed.